Mennonites prod government on Palestinian concerns

December 7, 2022 | News | Volume 26 Issue 25
Emma Siemens | CM Intern
Present-day Old Bethlehem. (Photo by Byron and Melita Rempel-Burkholder)

Christian Palestinians have asked the global church to stand with them, and Mennonites in Canada have now asked their government to do the same.

In September, Mennonite Church Canada’s Palestine-Israel Network (PIN) sent a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Mélanie Joly, the minister of foreign affairs, calling the government to consistency in its stance on Palestine and Israel.

“As people of faith, we know there is a new world coming, and we know that God wants peace and reconciliation,” says Byron Rempel-Burkholder, PIN’s chair, in an interview. “We keep trying to be a witness to that vision.”

The letter includes four calls to action:

  • As Canada’s policy names Israeli settlements as an “obstacle to peace,” the letter calls the government to restructure the Canada-Israel Free Trade Agreement to prevent the importation of goods from the Israeli settlements in the West Bank and Jerusalem.
  • The letter calls on Canada to support ongoing and future investigations into infractions of international law in Palestine and Israel, regarding the safety and freedom of journalists.
  • As Canada has condemned Amnesty International’s report identifying Israel as an apartheid state, the letter calls on Canada to support Israel in starting “renewed, good-faith negotiations” with Palestinians for “equal rights, dignity and self-determination.”
  • The letter urges the Canadian government to address reports of inhumane incarceration of children, by monitoring the treatment of Palestinian children in Israeli military detention.

The Palestine-Israel Network was established as a working group within MC Canada after a resolution on the matter was passed at the 2016 delegate assembly. The resolution acknowledged the injustice suffered by Palestinians under Israel’s military occupation and committed the nationwide church to work for justice in the region.

The working group is comprised of a nationwide leadership group and four regional church groups.

Mennonite ties to Palestine date back 73 years, and MC Canada has ongoing connections with Palestinian Christians.

Over the past six years, PIN has formed and strengthened connections with Christian Palestinian groups, Independent Jewish Voices and other secular parties working for justice in Palestine-Israel.

Rempel-Burkholder, who lived in Bethlehem for three months in 2016, says that these connections, along with the 2016 resolution and Anabaptist values in general, are what inspire and guide the group’s work, including the September letter.

“As a Christian community, we stand with each other in our suffering,” he says. “The Palestinian church asks us to support them, and so we’ve responded to that call.” For him, “that’s where Anabaptist values of community come into it.”

Referencing the “Kairos Document,” a landmark 2009 communique from Palestinian Christians, Rempel-Burkholder emphasizes that Palestinian sisters and brothers are saying they “want to be grounded in the love of God, not only for Palestinians, but also for Israelis, and part of loving is to speak truth to power.”

In that context, the good news is holistic. “We’re trying to be agents of good news and transformation,” he says. “But not a good news that is separated from peace and justice.” 

Advocating at the federal level is part of PIN’s work. While the Canadian government hasn’t responded to the network’s letter, the group has connected with multiple members of parliament. Government officials also did not respond to Canadian Mennonite’s request for comment.

“That’s where we need more of a groundswell,” says Rempel-Burkholder. Without broader help in contacting government, the justice PIN is seeking “isn’t going to make its way into government policy.” 

He encourages Mennonites in Canada to write to politicians, learn more about Palestine-Israel, and participate in learning tours. He also encourages Mennonites to get involved socially, by getting to know Palestinians in their communities and attending public events and protests.

“We’re hoping [that] with this persistent ‘kicking at the darkness,’ there’ll be some light and some change,” he says. “At times it seems futile, but we know we’re on the right side of history, so we just keep working at it.”

Read the PIN letter at

Related articles:
Challenging Holy Land stereotypes
2,000 years later in Bethlehem . . .

Present-day Old Bethlehem. (Photo by Byron and Melita Rempel-Burkholder)

Share this page: Twitter Instagram

Add new comment

Canadian Mennonite invites comments and encourages constructive discussion about our content. Actual full names (first and last) are required. Comments are moderated and may be edited. They will not appear online until approved and will be posted during business hours. Some comments may be reproduced in print.