You don’t have to be perfect

March 2, 2011 | Feature | Number 5
By Evelyn Rempel Petkau | Manitoba Correspondent
Erin Morash pastors at Trinity Mennonite Church in Mather and Crystal City Mennonite, rural Manitoba congregations 20 minutes apart.

It was the simple yet profound welcome she received as a stranger in a Mennonite church that made all the difference to Erin Morash, who says she grew up in “an extraordinarily secular family.”

When the family moved to Langham, Sask., in her adolescence, Morash chose to attend Zoar Mennonite. For the first time, she heard a peace theology expressed. “That and the music blew me away,” says Morash, who now pastors at Trinity Mennonite Church in Mather and Crystal City Mennonite, rural Manitoba congregations 20 minutes apart.

“The first time I asked about becoming a minister I was 19, in an adult Bible study group in Langham,” she says. “I got such good feedback from people in the Bible study group, and the pastor asked me to do a sermon.”

Morash began to explore what felt like a call to ministry. Friends within the church encouraged her, recognizing her gifts in studying the Bible. “But the idea horrified my mom,” she admits. And her grandmother told her, “You have to be perfect to be a Mennonite minister.”

“I decided I would finish my degree in history and then I would get away and take time to think about it,” she says. While at university, Morash became involved with women in abusive relationships. She studied the Scriptures with them, sometimes in secret, as they struggled with decisions of whether to stay or to leave those relationships. “I realized that this religion stuff, which up to that point I had taken to be quite personal, had incredible social power and consequences.”

When she completed her degree, she decided to go to Canadian Mennonite Bible College (now Canadian Mennonite University) in Winnipeg. In 1997 she completed her master of divinity degree. Following a pastoral internship at Langley Mennonite Fellowship in B.C., she was associate youth pastor at North Kildonan Mennonite in Winnipeg for eight years.

“I think because I walked in clueless, and because I wasn’t part of the denomination by birth, I was given permission to do things the insider couldn’t,” she muses. “That being said, there are ‘ins’ I don’t have, like family connections and subtle cultural understandings.”

Early in her ministry, Morash recalls a meeting of ministers at which she was mistaken for one of the servers and handed a cup of coffee to refill. When they realized she was one of the ministers, the conversation came to halt. “Please, God, don’t let it be like this every time,” she prayed.

And it hasn’t. When Morash was an associate pastor it was easier for those who had trouble with her gender to accept her leadership under a male lead pastor. Now in small rural communities as lead pastor, she says that “not everyone is equally accepting, and yet they have been so welcoming, coming every Sunday, bringing me into their homes, coming to Bible studies I lead. We eat together and pray together.”

Morash isn’t about trying to change minds: “I just try to follow my calling as faithfully as I can, owning up to the mistakes I make, as well as I can.”


Hi Erin, just wondering if you would be available to do our wedding this month? thanks. ph. 204-535-2114

Add new comment

Canadian Mennonite invites comments and encourages constructive discussion about our content. Actual full names (first and last) are required. Comments are moderated and may be edited. They will not appear online until approved and will be posted during business hours. Some comments may be reproduced in print.