Amish-Mennonite pastor convicted of abetting kidnapping

Could get up to three years in prison

August 17, 2012 | Web First
Lauren Markoe | Religion News Service
Middlebury, VT.

A Vermont jury found an Amish-Mennonite pastor guilty Tuesday (Aug. 14) of abetting an international kidnapping to keep a young girl from her lesbian parent.

Virginia pastor Kenneth Miller, of the Beachy Amish-Mennonite sect, helped Lisa Miller (no relation) flee the U.S. with her daughter Isabella, who's now 10. The pastor, who has become a hero among many religious conservatives who have followed the case, faces up to three years in prison.

Lisa Miller, who was part of a lesbian couple when Isabella was born, has since rejected homosexuality and declared herself a born-again Christian. She failed to live up to court orders that gave her former partner, Janet Jenkins, visitation rights with Isabella.

Kenneth Miller, prosecutors showed, helped arrange for Lisa Miller and her daughter to be driven to Canada and board a flight to Nicaragua in 2009, where his church runs a mission.

His lawyer argued that the pastor did not know he was flouting a custody ruling. Prosecutors, however, pointed out that the pastor took pains to hide some of his actions.

The Amish-Mennonites believe homosexuality is a sin. About 100 members of the sect sang “We Shall Overcome” outside the courthouse in Burlington where the pastor was convicted.

“We are of course disappointed,” the pastor said Tuesday after the verdict was read, according to The New York Times. “But with the grace of God and by his help, we will bear the consequences.”

Federal officials believe Lisa Miller and Isabella Miller-Jenkins are in Nicaragua, a country with which the U.S. has no extradition treaty.

Lisa Miller and Janet Jenkins entered into a civil union in Vermont in 2000; Lisa Miller gave birth to Isabella two years later after undergoing in vitro fertilization.

The custody battle over Isabella has made headlines since she was a toddler, when Lisa Miller moved from Vermont to Virginia, where a law bans the recognition of same-sex unions and marriages.

Even Virginia jurists have concluded, however, that federal anti-kidnapping statutes take precedence over the Virginia law and the federal Defense of Marriage Act. A Vermont judge indicated in 2009 that Jenkins would be awarded custody of Isabella if her former partner continued to defy visitation orders.

As the jury was deliberating Tuesday, Jenkins filed a lawsuit against Lisa Miller and Kenneth Miller, seeking unspecified monetary damages, according to The Associated Press.

A number of other organizations and individuals who allegedly conspired to help Lisa, according to Jeff Schapiro, writing for the Christian Post.  Among the defendants in the suit is the Liberty University School of Law.

Mathew Staver, dean of the school, once served as Lisa's attorney alongside Rena Lindevaldsen. Both attorneys allegedly "routinely instructed their Law School students that the correct course of action for a person in Lisa Miller's situation would be to engage in 'civil disobedience' and defy court orders," the suit claims.

Victoria Hyden (formerly Victoria Zodhiates), who was an assistant for the law school, is the daughter of Philip Zodhiates, who allegedly conspired with Kenneth and drove Lisa and Isabella to Canada as a part of their escape.

During Kenneth's criminal trial, U.S. attorneys shared phone records showing Zodhiates called a line belonging to the Liberty Counsel, a nonprofit legal organization founded by Staver, on his way back to Virginia from Canada. Staver told the Times that the number he called is a widely circulated public relations office number, and said he had no knowledge of Lisa's flight and never spoke with Zodhiates about her case.

The suit also alleges that the elders of Thomas Road Baptist Church in Lynchburg, Va., packed up Lisa's personal belongings for her in November 2009. Later, these belongings were allegedly picked up by Zodhiates, who arranged to have them transported to Nicaragua.

The suit also points out Falwell's support of The Manhattan Declaration, a document which says, in part, that Christians will not "bend to any rule purporting to force us to bless immoral sexual partnerships, treat them as marriages or the equivalent."

In addition to Liberty University Law School and Thomas Road Baptist Church, Response Unlimited (a company owned by Zodhiates), Christian Aid Ministries and several individuals are being accused of conspiring with Kenneth to help Lisa flee the country with Isabella.

No sentencing date for Kenneth Miller has been set.  He could get up to three years in prison.

--Aug. 17, 2012

Share this page: Twitter Instagram

Add new comment

Canadian Mennonite invites comments and encourages constructive discussion about our content. Actual full names (first and last) are required. Comments are moderated and may be edited. They will not appear online until approved and will be posted during business hours. Some comments may be reproduced in print.