I want you to image a soccer game, a game where play is going on, but a strange and discomforting noise is coming from the stands. Some players can play through it, but a few of them are quite distracted by the noise.
So what should be done about the noise?
Some say that this noise is just a part of the game, especially in certain countries, and that interfering wouldn’t be effective and would only stir up resentment in these parts of the world.
Others say that the noise is not only annoying and unnecessary, but potentially damaging to players and spectators, and is fundamentally detrimental to the game.
FIFA and the other sports governing bodies haven’t done much about it, likely hoping that the whole issue will just disappear, and maybe they’re right about that. Generally people feel that either they are radically opposed to it, or they understand the discomfort it causes but see the overall battle as not one that can be one and hopefully it is just a fad that will soon pass. Where do you stand?
I don’t need to clarify my own position first do I? If I do, then I will say unequivocally that I am anti-racism. If you’re asking what race has to do with vuvuzelas, my answer is that I’m not talking about vuvuzelas. I love the vuvuzelas. It’s a noise-maker at a sporting event, get over it. What I’m talking about doesn’t happen in Africa, it happens when players of African descent play in Europe, especially in the home of the most recent World Cup champions, Spain.
So I ask again, what should be done about the noise?
The ones who chant in this way are not in the majority, but there are enough racist fans that the chants are audible throughout the stadium and this isn’t a situation where building security could simply eject the individual offenders, they wouldn’t have the manpower to do this. The revolt from these fans would be immense. Or would it? FIFA has spoken out against this behaviour, but has done little as far as implementing punishments or concrete solutions. What would it look like if there were a World Cup of Racial Tolerance? I’m guessing the trophy would be awarded to a different country.
I recently went to a CFL game and a fan had brought a vuvuzela, and I heard a number of other fans around complaining about how those horns had negatively impacted the World Cup soccer tournament. I chose to see things differently. I’m sure nobody in South Africa blowing these horns intended it this way, but I saw it as a kind of revenge. I didn’t hear an annoying horn, I saw African people using an African invention to make noise that annoyed white European soccer players and white European soccer fans. To me, that wasn’t annoying, that was funny.
For every toot of a vuvuzela horn in South Africa this summer, a racist chant is shouted in Europe. Which one should be silenced? I say we all blow the vuvuzela until the racist chants stop.
Recent Comments